Environmental Protection Agency finalized its revision to the
Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) program in February, 2010.
Under the Energy Independence
and Security Act of 2007 (EISA), Congress created requirements for how
much renewable fuel (corn ethanol, biomass-based diesel, cellulosic
ethanol, and other "advanced "fuels) must be blended in the nation's
petroleum supply.
Although the revision does not change the fact that 36 billion
gallons of biofuels are required to be consumed in 2022, it does make
two significant changes.
RFS is that lifecycle GHG
emissions
First, one of the unique aspects of the RFS is that lifecycle GHG
emissions of qualifying renewable fuel must be less than lifecycle GHG
emissions of the 2005 baseline average gasoline or diesel fuel that it
replaces.

According to Green Tech Media, "when the EPA originally calculated indirect land use, corn ethanol was
found to have a higher carbon footprint than an equal gallon of
gasoline - and thus would not qualify under the RFS. The corn ethanol
lobby (i.e. Big Agriculture) cried foul and claimed that since there
was no universally agreed upon methodology for evaluating indirect-land
use effects, the EPA should shelve it. The corn ethanol lobby also
mobilized their Republican and Democratic friends in Congress who
subsequently threatened to pass laws taking away the EPA's power to
regulate "indirect land use" effects in life-cycle greenhouse gas
analysis."
Under the final determinations established Wednesday, the EPA ruled
that corn ethanol produced from a "new or expanded capacity from an
existing natural gas-fired facility using advanced efficient
technologies" complies with the 20% GHG emission threshold.
Advanced Biofuels
While the EPA kept in place the target of 36 billion
gallons of biofuel in 2022 (of which corn ethanol is not to exceed 15
billion gallons), it greatly reduced the amount of cellulosic ethanol
required to be blended in 2010 (from 100 million gallons to 6.5 million
gallons).
Cellulosic ethanol is a wonderful improvement over corn ethanol. There
are a plethora of non-food based feedstocks that can be used (e.g.
agricultural residues, woody biomass, municipal solid waste, etc) and
lifecycle greenhouse gases are lower due to the ability to burn the
lignin and co-generate electricity. Yet, the costs of producing a
gallon of cellulosic ethanol still remains higher than corn ethanol,
due to the expensive enzymes required for breaking down complex
polysaccharides into simple sugars for fermentation. BUT...The industry is coming to market much slower than anticipated.
While GreenTechMedia expects the first commercial facility to go online in 2010
(Range Fuel's 20 MGY facility in Colorado), 2012 should be the year
where a massive ramp up occurs (see GTM report Biofuels 2010: Spotting the Next Wave).